Wednesday, February 8, 2023
HomeCouple TravelHigh 10 Finest Key Lime Pie in Key West

High 10 Finest Key Lime Pie in Key West

Do you need to attempt the most effective Key Lime Pie in Key West? Then look no additional! We’ve received you coated on all issues Key Lime Pie. We’ve been on the hunt for the right Key Lime Pie and tasted among the finest in Key West.

For those who’re heading to the southernmost level of Florida, you’ve received to do that iconic dessert. Many locals and companies alike declare to have the unique recipe for Key Lime Pie. Although they’ll’t all maintain this title, they do all serve up irresistible Key Lime Pie. It’s candy, it’s tangy, and it originates from the final of Florida’s Keys.

Key Lime Pie is historically served with a graham cracker crust, and a zesty condensed milk filling. Many select so as to add whipped cream for further style and texture. Some even pile it excessive with a lifetime provide of meringue. Others have been recognized to step outdoors the confines of custom and use some unconventional taste mixtures and make a novel Key Lime Pie. However the important thing (pun supposed) to this dessert is the Key Lime juice. Domestically grown, actual Key Lime juice is what units this pie aside.

You might be somebody who opts for chocolate over one thing bitter. You’ll have tried Key Lime Pie earlier than. However I assure you’ve by no means tried something nearly as good as Key West Key Lime Pie. You possibly can virtually style the very fact it’s made with native substances and by native folks.

That is our information to the most effective Key Lime Pie in Key West. We’ve achieved our analysis as it’s our favourite dessert and we’re at all times up for some good Key Lime Pie. You’ll depart the island figuring out that you just’ll by no means have one other piece of pie this good!

What’s Key Lime Pie?

Key Lime Pie is a quintessential American dessert. This pie is made out of Key Lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, and pie crust. The pie will be served simply as it’s, topped with meringue, or coated in whipped cream. A conventional Key Lime Pie recipe makes use of graham crackers for the crust. Although many stick with the standard pie, some Key West eating places go somewhat maverick! Mango, passionfruit, and blueberry can be used for a novel slice of Key Lime Pie.

For those who aren’t up for making your individual, Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe ships their well-known Key Lime Pie and it’s truly cheaper than you’d suppose. Click on right here to view choices and order on-line.

Historical past of Key Lime Pie

Relying on who you ask, the historical past and origin of Key Lime Pie varies. It does nevertheless appear unanimous that the dessert originated in Key West. Many institutions and locals declare that their scrumptious Key Lime Pie recipe is the genuine one.

Lots of people consider Aunt Sally made the primary ever Key Lime Pie. She was the cook dinner of ship salvaging millionaire William Curry throughout the Nineteenth century. She apparently took the recipe from a fisherman and perfected the pie we all know at this time. William Curry constructed an expensive mansion in 1855, that you would be able to keep in at this time. The Curry Mansion Inn claims to be the unique makers of Key Lime Pie.

Essentially the most important ingredient on this dessert is after all actual Key Limes. The Key Lime tree most likely got here to the Florida Keys throughout the 1500s from Malaysia. Although industrial Key Lime manufacturing was widespread throughout the 1800s, at this time it’s not frequent. Key Lime bushes are solely actually present in backyards and utilized by locals to make this pleasant pie.

bowl of Key Limes used for the best Key Lime Pie


Why is Key West well-known for Key Lime Pie?

It’s believed that this well-known pie originated from the southernmost Florida Key, Key West. The juice in Key Lime Pie comes from Key Lime bushes. In distant Key West, refrigeration was laborious to come back by. So folks would use condensed milk as a substitute of milk. This sparked the beginning of the concept of utilizing this ingredient to make Key Lime Pie. At the moment the Key Lime Pie custom continues. There are such a lot of superb eating places in Key West to select up an amazing Key Lime Pie.

The place is the Finest Key Lime Pie in Key West?

One of the best Key Lime Pie in Key West is a hotly contested subject. Locals merely can’t agree who has the most effective pies, with many having their very own common go-to Key Lime Pie haunts. One of the vital widespread locations to take pleasure in a slice (or two) is Kermit’s. Their candy however bitter pie is the right sugar repair. Take a look at our greatest Key West Key Lime Pie spots and select your favourite.

Kermit's Key Lime Pie Key West

1. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe

The Meals Community awarded Kermit’s the ‘Finest Key Lime Pie in Key West’ title. We’d should agree, that Kermit’s is without doubt one of the finest Key Lime Pies in Key West. Kermit’s serves a standard Key Lime Pie recipe with a buttery graham cracker crust and whipped cream. Select a whole pie, a slice, or chocolate coated frozen Key Lime Pie on a stick. You’ll be in pie heaven at Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe.

Their frozen pie bars are dipped in scrumptious Belgian chocolate. The right deal with for a sizzling day within the Key West solar. In addition they serve up gluten-free Key Lime Pie that’s simply as scrumptious as the unique.

Kermit’s turned so widespread they opened up a second Key West location. Their Elizabeth Road store serves up breakfast, lunch, and naturally, Key Lime Pie. In case you are in search of a fast reasonably priced lunch Kermit’s Cafe has actually good salads and wraps.

Kermit’s can be an amazing place to seize some pie themed souvenirs. Their store sells Kermit’s clothes, Key Lime cleaning soap, and even Key Lime lip balm! We at all times choose up a bottle of Key Lime juice made with genuine Key Limes, we prefer to make Key Lime cocktails at residence throughout the summer season. You may even see Kermit Carpenter himself there, you gained’t miss him in his key lime inexperienced apparel.

  • View menu 
  • Deal with: 200 Elizabeth Road Key West, 431 Entrance Road, Key West

2. Key Lime Pie Bakery

A bakery whose title consists of Key Lime Pie has so much to dwell as much as. So it’s a very good job Key Lime Pie Bakery serves among the most interesting Key Lime Pie. together with different delights. The bakery’s authentic household recipe makes use of 100% pure Key Lime juice. There’s simply at all times one thing satisfying about figuring out you’re tasting a household secret.

Their graham cracker crust pies are served by the slice or an entire pie. They make a moreish Key Lime Pie mousse and Key West favourite, chocolate-dipped pie. It’s also possible to purchase their Key Lime focus to take residence. Strive creating your individual Key West Key Lime Pie recipe.

  • Deal with: 412 Greene St., Key West

best restaurant in Key West Blue Haven outside

3. Blue Heaven

For those who don’t look after custom, you’ll love Blue Heaven’s Key Lime Pie. They’re recognized for his or her yummy meringue topped pie. Their graham cracker crust pie is topped with a very beneficiant 6-inch serving of meringue! Their pie will ship any meringue lover right into a state of sugary euphoria.

Key Lime Pie isn’t their solely draw. Many head to Blue Heaven for ‘Breakfast with the Roosters’ on their out of doors patio. They’re one of many finest eating places in Key West for breakfast. There’s a shabby bohemian vibe to this place. Plastic chairs, a makeshift tin-roofed bar, and home made indicators make for a characterful go to. You’ll want to head there early as there are not any reservations. Get pleasure from pancakes, home made granola, banana bread, and extra, all with the sound of crowing roosters.

4. Previous City Bakery

The family-owned Previous City Bakery is ready in a standard Key West residence. The couple homeowners had been decided to maintain its Nineteenth-century Key West appeal. They stored the Dade County pine partitions and the uncovered beams. The genuine Florida Keys appeal actually does praise their genuine baking.

The Previous City Bakery is a well-liked locals favourite spot. Early within the morning, you’ll discover a bustling crowd having fun with pastries, espresso, and good dialog. They serve pastries, breads, crunchy baguette sandwiches, artisanal cheese, and naturally Key Lime Pie.

They had been awarded ‘Finest Key Lime Pie within the Florida Keys’ by Miami New Occasions. Extra proof that Key West is the place to go for this tangy dessert. Choose up a slice or an entire pie, their Key Lime Pie comes with contemporary whipped cream.

The place to Discover the Finest Seafood in Key West

5. Moondog Cafe & Bakery

The Moondog Cafe & Bakery is a very Instagrammable spot. The place is roofed in murals, together with ones that includes their cute French Bulldog mascot. The decor is on level, and so they’ve created a welcoming and vigorous house to eat.

They serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and also you guessed it, in addition they have among the tastiest Key Lime Pies. They’ve a wide selection of meals to select from too. Strive the Quiche Lorraine, Breakfast Burritos, burgers, pizza, and treats from the bakery. The bakery sells croissants, Key Lime Pie, eclairs, muffins, and zucchini bread. There are additionally a variety of gluten-free and vegan choices. There actually is one thing for everybody.

It’s a good spot to seize a seat of their cozy out of doors seating space for the most effective ambiance. It’s beautiful at night time with the hanging lights and chattering friends.

  • View Menu
  • Deal with: 823 Whitehead St., Key West

6. Key West Key Lime Pie Co

This place’s motto is “if we don’t make it, we don’t promote it”. They’re all about genuine meals made contemporary on web site. They’re finest recognized for his or her conventional household Key Lime Pie recipe. Their pies are a graham cracker base, topped with spirals of whipped cream.

They haven’t simply settled for less than serving genuine pie. They’ve created some unique and revolutionary taste mixtures. Whereas die-hard Key Lime Pie followers might stick up their noses, dessert lovers gained’t. Strive mango, blueberry, or toasted coconut for one thing somewhat totally different. In addition they have gluten-free pies and chocolate-covered pie on a stick.

One thing distinctive you are able to do right here goes to a Key Lime Pie class, it was considered one of our favourite issues to do in Key West. Whip up your individual mini Key Lime Pie proper within the firm’s personal kitchen. Afterward take pleasure in among the finest Key Lime Pie in Key West, handmade by you! This can be a nice exercise for youths in case you are on a household trip, aspiring bakers, and naturally pie lovers. This is without doubt one of the go-to locations in Key West to attempt Key Lime Pie.

  • Deal with: 511 Greene St., Key West

7. Sarabeth’s

Of the most effective Key Lime Pie in Key West, Sarabeth’s is a good selection. It’s a widespread spot for brunch and dinner. Head there any day of the week to take pleasure in top-of-the-line breakfasts in Key West. They satisfaction themselves on their contemporary and fashionable tackle traditional American dishes. The Lemon Ricotta Pancakes are an actual crowd-pleaser. Their Key Lime Pie French Toast is a intelligent twist on a traditional breakfast deal with. In addition they do quesadillas, veggie burgers, and different yummy dishes.

You could spherical off a meal at Sarabeth’s with a slice of their Key Lime Pie. They use a standard Key Lime Pie recipe that’s bursting with taste. Different widespread desserts embrace the Strawberry Shortcake, Chocolate Pudding, and Orange Apricot Bread Pudding.

Miami to Key West – High Street Journey Stops

8. The Cafe

Calling all vegans, that is the right place for you! The Cafe has the most effective VEGAN Key Lime Pie in Key West. In truth, they’re the one place that serves vegan Key Lime Pie. For those who don’t fancy Key Lime Pie, then there are different vegan choices too. Carrot cake and chocolate cake are simply two different vegan delights, there are lots extra!

Go to for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, and don’t fear in addition they serve non-vegan dishes. Breakfast is tremendous widespread with tons of veggie, vegan, and traditional choices on supply.

  • View menu 
  • Deal with: 509 Southard St., Key West

9. Mattheessen’s 

Mattheessen’s has two shops, one on busy Duval Road in Key West and the opposite on Greene Road. They began with a small espresso kiosk, then opened a fudge and cookie retailer. Now Mattheessen’s is a cache of all of your selection candy treats, together with Key Lime Pie. They’re finest recognized for his or her big cookies and yummy ice cream. Their conventional Key Lime Pie slice has change into an actual crowd pleaser. In addition they serve up Key Lime Pie on a stick, dipped in Belgium darkish chocolate.

For those who’re after a late-night sugar repair, Mattheessen’s has received you coated. They’re open until midnight, so you possibly can seize this candy Key West meals.

  • Deal with: 419 Duval St., Key West, 106 Duval St., Key West, 614 Greene St., Key West.

10. Cafe Marquesa

Cafe Marquesa is without doubt one of the finest eating places in Key West and nicely price a go to. It’s one of many highest-rated eating places within the space, serving up New American fares. Cafe Marquesa is the right location for a date or dinner with pals. There’s a stunning ambiance and also you’ll quickly see why it’s many individuals’s favourite place.

For dinner, you possibly can go for the Crispy Yellowtail Snapper or the duck breast. In addition to regionally sourced Key West meals, they’re recognized for his or her house-made desserts. Their Key Lime Pie is topped with whipped cream and walnuts and is divine. In addition they have a liquid Key Lime Pie, with RumChata Limón, Key Lime Rum, and cream. I’m drooling simply enthusiastic about it! For those who love key lime taste you need to attempt it.

Flawless presentation and a mixture of fantastic and informal eating, make this top-of-the-line locations to go.

Who do you suppose has the most effective Key Lime Pie in Key West? We’re at all times desirous to attempt new eating places in Key West!

This publish might comprise affiliate hyperlinks, see our disclosure



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments