Tuesday, February 7, 2023
HomeTravel PhotographyGreatest Pizza in Key West

Greatest Pizza in Key West

In search of one of the best pizza in Key West? At solely 4 miles lengthy and one mile large, this little island packs in a ton of attractive sights, from beach-combing to consuming your means round city and a few tasty pizza locations too.

Within the culinary world, Key West is understood for serving up a number of the freshest seafood anyplace. Although it’s possible you’ll be stunned to seek out out that there’s some nice pizza in Key West to be discovered. Few meals can evaluate to the saucy, tacky mouthful {that a} good slice supplies.

Let’s be sincere, anyplace on the earth you go, it’s important to know the place the superior pies are being slung. Under are all the professional suggestions for locating one of the best pizza in Key West.


1. Onlywood Pizzeria

Onlywood Pizzeria is a family-owned and operated neighborhood hang-out. It’s a standard trattoria-style spot that first opened in 2012. The shining star of the house is the huge 100% genuine brick oven imported straight from Napoli. It will possibly attain as much as 1000 levels, which is good for Neapolitan pies.

All of the components are completely Italian, right down to the imported San Marzano sauce. They even make their very own mozzarella utilizing an historical recipe. There’s an extended record of specialty creations, and a brand new one to strive every day. For a traditional, order the Acciughe and for one thing barely extra daring, go for the Pistacchio.

  • Menu
  • Handle: 613-1/2 Duval St, Key West

2. Clements Wooden-Hearth Trolley Pizzeria

What began as making pizza out of a refurbished classic trolley in 2014, has since grown right into a full-service restaurant. Century-old artisan traditions are used to create completely cooked pies. The components are contemporary and the dough is left to rise for 36 hours, giving it that superb Neapolitan crust texture.

It’s a energetic and laid-back spot, usually blasting rock tunes and there’s sidewalk seating as nicely. Their specialty is the Honey Bacon Pizza, and belief me after I say you received’t wish to miss out on it.

  • Handle: 516 Fleming St, Key West

3. Duetto Pizza and Gelato

Duetto is all about bringing locals and vacationers collectively for that good slice of pizza. It’s regionally owned and operated, they usually’ve received many awards over time. You possibly can order a single slice or a complete pie right here. The dough is made contemporary each day with semolina and hits that candy spot of being not too thick and never too skinny.

The Polpette, which interprets to “meatballs,” will get rave evaluations right here. I at all times like to try to seize a lunch particular for a brilliant reasonably priced and engaging meal in Key West.

  • Menu
  • Handle: 540 Greene St, Key West

4. Mr. Z’s Outdated City

Mr. Z’s is an establishment within the space and serves up extra than simply pizza. The genuine Italian sandwiches, made both sizzling or chilly, is simply as a lot of a draw, particularly their cheesesteak. You will get one of the best of each worlds right here and order the Cheesesteak Pizza!

In any other case, the Tomato Pie and White Pie are the highest picks and are each customizable with a variety of gourmand toppings. They’re open every single day of the week, and even till 4:00 am on the weekends, in case you’re craving a late-night slice. It’s the good place to come back after an evening out visiting a number of the greatest bars in Key West.

  • Menu
  • Handle: 501 Southard St, Key West

5. Roostica

Roostica is a wood-fired pizzeria broadly thought of to be a favourite in Key West. The open kitchen permits you to watch the cautious and genuine preparation of the pie you picked because it slides out and in of the spectacular oven. The house feels hip and high-end, for a really satisfying eating expertise. 

The dough is made with solely tender grain flour, yeast, water, and sea salt. Solely Italian plum tomatoes, mozzarella di buffalo, additional virgin olive oil, and contemporary basil are used to prime it. It doesn’t get rather more conventional for Neapolitan pizzas than that. They boast an in depth menu with one thing for everybody, although ordering the Sicilian Deep Dish is suggested should you ask me.

  • Menu
  • Handle: 5620 MacDonald Ave, Key West

6. New York Pasta Backyard

New York Pasta Backyard has been a foodie staple on the island since 1989. The proprietor is from New York and fortunate for us has introduced his love for all issues Italian to Key West. They’re recognized for large parts, artistic delicacies, and tropical cocktails.

New York Pasta Backyard is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner all out there for take out, supply, and eating in. There’s a variety of dishes to strive right here, together with pasta bakes, seafood, and barbecue. The backyard house is beautiful, with loads of foliage, twinkle lights, and charming wood tables. The garlic bread that begins off each meal free of charge is a scrumptious bonus as nicely.

  • Menu
  • Handle: 1075 Duval St, Key West


7. Moon Canine Cafe

The Moon Canine Cafe is a superb selection for breakfast, lunch, or dinner in Key West. There’s a bakery on-site for all types of freshly baked goodies each day. They’re recognized round city for having one of many greatest breakfasts in Key West, however additionally they have a number of the greatest pizza in Key West. It’s an throughout lovable outpost with a brightly coloured Cuban aptitude, out of doors seating, a full bar, and lots of murals.

There are many gluten-free and vegan choices right here, together with grilled pizzas. They’ve some tremendous enjoyable topping choices like Moroccan Lamb, Shrimp, and Bacon, or Fig and Gorgonzola. It’s enjoyable to check out the shareable plates to begin off with or snack on right here, just like the Solid Iron Truffle Mac and Cheese or the Grilled Vegetable Charcuterie.

  • Menu
  • Handle: 823 Whitehead St, Key West

Associated Article: Greatest Cuban Meals in Key West


8. Sea Aspect Cafe on the Mansion

Everybody goes to the Sea Aspect Cafe on the Mansion for the well-known Lobster Pizza, and it truly is a should strive. All of their artisan wood-fired pizzas are out of this world although. The Duval Road Corn and Scorching Honey Salami pies come an in depth second as nicely if you wish to strive a couple of.

Simply steps away from the nice and cozy Atlantic Ocean, the surroundings at this historic and charming spot makes it much more value your whereas. It’s owned by a father and son group, and they’re pet and household pleasant! If you’re spending the day on one of many greatest seashores in Key West it’s the good place to pop in for lunch and a few shade too. 

  • Menu
  • Handle: 1400 Duval St, Key West

9. Off The Hook Grill

Off The Hook Grill is a cute and comfortable eatery for pizza within the Key West. The meals right here is impressed by flavors from all around the world. The private pizzas might be adjusted for any gluten-free or vegan diners.

They’ve the extra traditional topping selections just like the Italian or the Greek, however they actually shine of their funkier specialty creations. The Crab Rangoon, Duck BLT, and BBQ Pork are a couple of of the native favorites. They’re open every single day besides Wednesday. There’s the principle bar and eating room and a patio, in addition to a separate pub house. The joyful hour drink specials are at all times a wonderful motive to test this one out.

  • Menu
  • Handle: 920 Caroline St, Key West

Associated Article: Greatest Eating places in Key West

10. Angelina’s Pizzeria

Angelina’s Pizzeria solely has a couple of sorts of pizzas out there, however you will get all of them gluten-free or by the slice. They provide loaded, veggie lovers, meat lovers, Hawaiian, and cheese pizzas. They’re recognized round city for having one of the best cheese pizza in Key West, which is sort of a feat amongst connoisseurs.

One of many coolest facets of the menu right here is that they provide a couple of completely different sizzling sauce choices by Peppers of Key West. The Garlic Bread at all times makes a tremendous addition to any order right here. The funky decor makes it tremendous satisfying to cease into, with classic arcade video games, a black and white checkered flooring, and sticker-covered partitions.

  • Menu
  • Handle: 208 Duval St, Key West

What restaurant do you assume has one of the best pizza in Key West? 

This submit could comprise affiliate hyperlinks, see our disclosure



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments